Ouran Host Club: Anime v. Manga


I told myself that I'd wait for the anime to end before I read the manga. But then I walked into the library and there were three volumes of Ouran just sitting there, staring at me, and, really, how could I refuse? And then I told myself that I'd only read the stories that have already been animated so as not to spoil myself. Well, that didn't work out as planned either. I've now read the first five volumes, and am glad that I did. But which is better, the anime or the manga?
Points for the anime:
In the beginning of the manga, I was turned off a bit by the character designs--Haruhi's eyes are too big and alien-like and the twins' flat hair is not as appealing as the spiked look they have in the anime and later on in the manga. While the drawings improved and later on were quite good, the animation has been very good all the way through.
Furthermore, in stories such as the beach episode, the anime really did improve things just by being able to make the action more clear. However, by volume 4--and definitely in volume 5--I believe that the art style became a lot smoother and that the mangaka (Bisco Hatori) had improved greatly in planning her panels so that the action flowed better.
One of the things I also liked in the anime better than the manga is the fact that the anime adds a bit more depth and symbolism. For example, in the first episode a lightbulb in a line of six goes off every time a Host Club member realizes that Haruhi is actually a girl (no such thing in the manga). And in the Alice in Wonderland episode (13), the anime takes a silly, throw-away chapter and turns it into something that really shows Haruhi's character (and is a bit of a mind-trip, to boot).
Points for the manga:
Of course, the nice thing about the manga is that it can throw in author's notes and details that the anime skips out on. For instance, the reason why all the Host Club members are in Class A of whatever year they are is explained. It's because which class a student is in is determined by their family's wealth and influence, with Class A being composed of the kids from the best families (Haruhi, as a scholarship student, is a special case and gets put in class A despite her low socio-economic status).
Organization (Or, Guide to Which Chapter Got Turned Into Which Episode Thus Far)
In terms of organization, the anime chose to change the order of the stories somewhat. I think it worked out, and neither the anime nor the manga had a "better" way to organize.
Note: In the manga, each chapter is called an "episode". But I'm calling them chapters because it makes it less confusing.
Volume 1
Chapter 1: Haruhi joins the Host Club ("From Today On, You're a Host" Ep 1)
Chapter 2: The Host Club helps get a couple together ("A High School Host's Work" Ep 2)
Chapter 3: The otaku Renge appears, claims to be Kyoya's fiance, then assigns herself the role of club manager ("The Manageress Invades" Ep 4)
Volume 2
Chapter 4: The physical exams are taking place, and the Host Club worries that the school will discover Haruhi's a girl ("Be Careful with Physical Exams" Ep 3)
Chapter 5: The twins have a fight ("The Twins Fight" Ep 5)
Chapter 6: An elementary school student apprentices himself to the Host Club ("The Elementary School Host is the Naughty Type" Ep 6)
Chapter 7: The Host Club goes to Kyoya's family new indoor water park facility ("Jungle Pool SOS" Ep 7)
Volume 3
Chapter 8: The beach part I ("Sun and Sea and the Host Club" Ep 8)
Chapter 9: The beach part II ("Sun and Sea and the Host Club" Ep 8)
Chapter 10: The St. Lobelia's Zuka club tries to recruit Haruhi ("The Lobelia Girls' Academy's Challenge" Ep 9)
Chapter 11: The Halloween episode in which Haruhi might be under a witch's curse (Not yet animated)
Chapter 12: The Host Club visits Haruhi's house Part I ("Fujioka Household's Daily Life" Ep 10)
Volume 4
Chapter 13:The Host Club visits Haruhi's house Part II ("Fujioka Household's Daily Life" Ep 10)
Chapter 14: Hunny gets a cavity and can't eat his beloved sweets ("Hunny-Senpai's Three Unsweetened Days" Ep 12)
Chapter 15: Retelling of Alice in Wonderland, Host Club style ("Haruhi in Wonderland" Ep 13)
Chapter 16: The newspaper club plans an expose on the Host Club ("Collect Information on the Rumored Host Club" Ep 14)
Volume 5
Chapter 17: Haruhi has to take a make-up test to regain her number 1 class standing, or risk losing her scholarship (not yet animated)
Chapter 18: The Host Club in Karuizawa Part I [contest to be the most "refreshing"] (not yet animated)
Chapter 19: The Host Club in Karuizawa Part II [Haruhi's middle school friend appears] (not yet animated)
Chapter 20: The Host Club in Karuizawa Part III [Haruhi's & Hikaru's date] (not yet animated)
Chapter 21: Nekozawa's (the Black Magic Club's President) little sister thinks Tamaki is her brother ("Onii-chama's the Prince" Ep 11)
So, so far they've only animated stories in volumes 1-5, having animated all of 1, 2, & 4. I hope they animate Chapter 11, because it's one of my favorites. Also, I'm highly anticipating the animation of the Karuizawa arc, because that is my absolute favorite at the moment (Episode 15, entitled "Karuizawa's Invigorating Battle" seems like it will cover at least part of the Karuizawa arc) . I wonder if they'll give Karuizawa one episode or two? Considering how cleverly the animators do added, non-manga scenes (like the first part of Episode 12), I think that two episodes for the Karuizawa arc would make it better.
Opinion: The anime wins the battle so far.
I think that the anime has taken an already excellent source and turned it into something even better. Of course, my opinion is subject to shifting if the manga continues to get better and if the anime has a less-than-satisfying conclusion or for some reason goes down hill in the second half.
As a side note, I've noticed that my favorite episodes and manga chapters center around either Tamaki/Haruhi or the twins/Haruhi. While Hunny is cute, and Mori is nice, I don't care as much for episodes centered around them. And when minor characters butt in and become the focus of the episode (like the Zuka club members or Nekozawa & his sister) I am not as interested in that, either (in fact, episodes 9 & 11 were my least favorite episodes--although, since this is Ouran, I still liked them).





















